Wednesday, December 15, 2010

Treasuries? More Like Trashuries!

I mentioned a couple months ago that I might want to talk about the bond bubble at some point.  Well we recently started to see some news that the bond market could be collapsing so I decided to finally dive in.  I've gotta admit, the whole process is a little tricky to understand and I'm not going to pretend to be an expert.  Every time I do some research on the subject, it just leaves me with more questions than I started with, but I'll do my best anyway. 

When the federal government runs a budget deficit, that budget has to get funded somehow.  Well, since it's a budget deficit, that means the treasury doesn't have enough money from taxes to fund the budget.  So what they do is sell "treasury securities" (also called "treasuries" or "securities".  I'll use those terms interchangeably).  An investor (bank, individual, foreign government, etc.) buys those treasuries, the treasury gets extra money and the budget gets funded.  The securities are then paid back to the investor after a period of time, with interest of course.

These securities come in 3 forms.  The first type of treasury securities are called T-bills.  They are short term securities that generally mature in a year or less.  Another type is called T-notes and they mature in 2-5 years.  The last type of security is called T-bonds.  They are the longest term and mature in up to 30 years.

Ok, that's basically all you need to know.  At least it better be, because that's basically all I know.

As I mentioned before, the treasury department will sell these securities to fund budget deficits.  Sometimes, the federal reserve (the fed) will announce that they want to buy some of these securities in order to increase the money supply.  That is called quantitative easing and it's how the fed gets money into the system in order to stimulate it.  But the fed cannot buy directly from the treasury.  I think it's actually a law.  So what the fed does is it tells certain banks that it deals with that they are going to buy up some securities.  The banks wheel and deal and make bids to the fed and whoever has the lowest bid gets to sell the securities to the fed.  Long story short, the banks buy treasuries from the treasury and then sells them to the fed, at a higher price of course.

Banks give cash to the treasury, the treasury can fund the debt, and then the federal reserve pays the banks.  That's where it gets interesting.  When the fed buys the securities from the bank, it does so with new money.  Money that never existed before.  Money that has nothing tangible backing it up.  Fiat money.  Money that's not worth the paper it's printed on.  Actually, they don't even really print the money.  They just add a few zeros to the bank's balance sheet.  The money is all digitized, created out of thin air and added to a computer as 1's and 0's.  I guess you could say it's money that isn't worth the paper that it's not printed on.  Anyway, that's where all the inflation fear comes from.  More money starts to chase the same number of goods and inflation is the result.

I mentioned that the different types of securities all have different rates of maturity.  A lot of the debt that has been funded in the past year or so has been with the short term T-bills because the interest rate is so low.  When those T-bills mature, then the treasury has to pay back the principle and interest.  But remember, that money was used for funding the government.  When those T-bills come back, the treasury will still have to sell many of those same bills again, plus a lot more to service the new debt on the new budget deficit that congress passed in the meantime.  It's as if you max out your credit card but can't afford to pay it off at the end of the month and your solution is to get 2 more credit cards.  One to pay off your first card and another one to buy more stuff you can't afford.  Actually, you are doing that because it's your money that they're spending.  Neat, huh?

When the global financial crisis hit, a lot of people rushed to buy treasury securities.  The conventional wisdom is that when everything else is doing poorly, the safest place to have your money is in American guaranteed dollars. I guess old habits die hard.  With so many people wanting to buy bonds and bills and notes from the treasury, the treasury didn't have to offer a whole lot of interest to the buyer.  The interest rate on the 30 year bond went down to about 3.5%.  That's extremely low.  It also means that it's extremely cheep for the treasury to service the federal debt.  That means that congress is more likely to have budget deficits and issue more debt.  That cycle continues, and it can only exist with plenty of people willing to buy treasuries and low interest rates.

But what happens if people start to get the mindset that the only thing worse than owning the dollar today is to own a promise to be paid in dollars 30 years from now?  People, banks and foreign governments can sell those bonds on the open market.  If you're worried about inflation, you would probably want to sell your $100 treasury bond for $80.  That way you get today's dollars and not an inflated, worthless dollar in 30 years.  Then it becomes more difficult for the treasury to sell new bonds unless they raise the interest rate.  Would you buy a $100 bond from the treasury when you can get it from someone else for $80?  Not unless the treasury was going to offer a much higher interest rate on the new bond.

But as I said before, all of these budget deficits were only possible because the treasury could find buyers of their securities and the interest rates were so low.  When interest rates rise, then the treasury goes into more debt and does so faster because it's paying more interest to service that debt.  And without new money coming in, either in the form of a budget surplus (feel free to laugh at that) or new bond buyers, it becomes impossible to fund government.  Unless of course congress stops funding government services beyond what it can afford (feel free to laugh at that) or the fed comes to the rescue and buys up those securities in exchange for a few extra digits on a bank's balance sheet punched into a computer that represents money.  And it seems extremely likely that the fed will do just that.  If you're expecting this new congress to cut spending in any significant way, well, let's just say I wouldn't hold my breath.

Why would the fed do this if it will cause high inflation?  First, they claim that injecting new money into the system will cause job creation.  Second, it's possible that the treasury is having a tough time finding buyers for their treasuries.  That would mean that the treasury has to pay much higher interest on our debt.  We currently pay about a half a trillion dollars on interest alone.  If rates rise even moderately, we could easily be paying over a trillion dollars a year on interest, not to mention the principle.

Why would congress continue to issue more debt?  Because the alternative is to take government services away from people.  Trust me, if they started to do that, there would be a lot of angry people.  Once the government starts to provide a service to people, the people become dependent on that service and feel like it is essential to their lives.  Then it's nearly impossible to make cuts to those services without political backlash.  Hell, even the tea party people are against cuts to medicare and social security, which are by far two of the largest contributors to the deficit.

Without any other buyers of treasury securities, and without major spending cuts, the only thing we can do to keep the gravy train rolling, at least for a while, is to have the fed buy treasury securities and wait for the inflation to steal any wealth we may have.

SIGNS THE PARTY IS ALMOST OVER:

One main reason we can have such low interest rates is because Moody's gives us a AAA rating.  They recently said that could change if budget deficits continue to increase.

There are some early signs that investors are selling off their treasury securities.  Last week saw the largest 2 day sell off since the collapse of Lehman Brothers in 2008.

The interest rate on the 10 year treasury note recently reached a 6 month high, and most economists expect the trend to continue.

Last November gave us a budget deficit of $150.4 billion.  That's the largest November budget deficit in history.

It's not just the new tax deal without spending cuts that has the world spooked about our economy.  The truth is that the world reacted very negatively when the fed announced a new round of quantitative easing back in November. 

The American public is also losing faith in the effectiveness of the fed.

Investors all around the world are starting to realize that there is no way American can ever pay back its debt.  David Bloom, currency chief at HCBS, recently said "If yields are rising because people think America's fiscal situation is unsustainable, then its Armaggedon."  There is also growing concern among investors that the federal reserve simply doesn't care about the dangers of inflation.  This is making owners of treasuries very nervous.  Stephen Lewis of Monument Securities also said "There is a feeling that the fed doesn't care about inflation, in fact wants more of it, and that is certainly not in the interest of bondholders"

Over the next 12 months, the U.S. government is going to be rolling over trillions of dollars in debt (the treasury securities will be maturing) along with all of the new borrowing that it is going to be doing. In fact, the U.S. government is somehow going to have to find a way to finance debt that is 27.8% of GDP in 2011.

For decades our leaders have told us that "deficits don't matter".  What we're all going to find out is - spoiler alert - our politicians have been lying to us.  The sad part is that most people still don't understand the magnitude of our debt problems.  As the federal government's total debt approaches 14 trillion dollars, that only represents a small fraction of the real problem.  The government has reached a "fiscal gap" of 202 trillion dollars.  That "real debt" includes our current federal debt plus all the other unfunded liabilities that the government has made commitments to pay but has no actual plan or ability to pay.  Just to put it in perspective, if the government taxed 100% of everyone's money in the country, it would have to do so for nearly 13.5 years to pay off that "real debt".  Does anyone actually think we'll ever pay that money back?

Let me try to recap the federal government's actions into a very simple statement.  Our national debt needs a continual source of new treasuries buyers in order to pay off the old buyers of treasuries once they mature.  Without a new supply of buyers, we can't pay the people we promised money to.

What I just described there is the textbook definition of a Ponzi scheme.  They are exactly the same.  Tweak a few words and those two sentences could also read like this: Bernie Madoff needed a continual source of new investors in order to pay off the old investors once they retired.  Without a new supply of investors, he couldn't pay the people he promised money to.... and anyone who was financially invested in him lost everything they had.

As a citizen and a taxpayer, we're all financially invested in the federal government.  And thanks to our government, the entire economy is one gigantic Ponzi scheme.

Wednesday, November 17, 2010

Obama is the perfect president, so don't let him do much.

My reach is global
My tower secure
My cause is noble
My power is pure
I can hand out a million vaccinations
Or let them all die from exasperation
Have them all healed from their lacerations
Or have them all killed by assassination
                                                          -Flobots

I try to avoid discussing President Obama for a few reasons, mostly because the conversation usually misses the point.  On TV you'll see lunatics on the right who claim that he's purposefully trying to destroy the country so he and the lefties can rebuild it in their image.  You'll also see lunatics on the left claim that he's the smartest and greatest person to ever hold elected office and we need to let him do whatever he can to fix the terrible mess he inherited.  He understands the issues better than anyone and, given that, he should have carte blanche to do whatever is necessary to fix the problems.  This post will mostly address the people who support Obama and his policies, and I'll attempt to explain why even his strongest supporters shouldn't support many of his decisions, even if they're the right ones.

For the sake of argument, I'm going to have to make a few assumptions, many of which aren't even too far off from how I really feel about the guy.  Since I'm addressing the Obama supporters, I'll have the assumptions cater to their arguments and views, and take them to the extreme to make my point.  Let's assume that he is the smartest person in any room he enters.  Let's assume that he has a greater understanding of the issues than anyone else and he is 100% right on everything.  Let's assume that he has the country's best interest in mind and will not ever be corrupted in any way.  And let's even go so far as to assume that every decision that he makes is perfect in every way and ushers in a new, unprecedented era of prosperity for not only the country but every single individual.  Everything he does and every law he passes is perfect, great and pure in every way.  The Health Care Law is the perfect law to fix the problems in the industry.  The war in Afghanistan is being waged in the perfect way, killing only those people we want to kill without harming innocent civilians or disrupting their society in any negative way.  The trillions spent on stimulus and bailouts work exactly the way they should and we see economic growth like we've never seen before, leaving nobody behind and benefiting all.  Essentially he is a perfect, magnanimous, benevolent and wise leader, like Bill Pullman in Independence Day, only better.  Let's start from there.

So what should we do, given the assumptions that I laid out above?  The easy answer would be to step back and let him work his magic.  Let him make the tough decisions and give him whatever he needs in order to follow through with them.  Whatever changes he wants to make to health care, we should support him.  Any amount of money he wants to spend to improve the economy, we should support him.  After all, any decision he makes is going to have amazing results and we won't have to give up any freedoms to accomplish them.  What would be the result of this course of action?  Well, given the assumptions that I made, we would certainly find ourselves living in a Utopian society in a very short period of time, and supporting Obama in all of his endeavors would certainly lead to great and amazing results.  

There's only one problem with doing that though.  At some point President Obama will leave office.  Even if he is so wonderful that we let him be our president for life and an entire generation grows up in a perfect society with a perfect leader, at some point he will die.*  And when he is no longer the president, we will have to elect a new one.  That new president will suddenly have all the power and authority that we gave to Obama, and the chances are pretty good that the new president won't be able to manage all that power in such a great way.

You see, the power of the Presidency sticks around much longer than any one president, so when we give any power to an elected official, we're also giving that power to everyone else who holds the office in the future.  This is something we all know, but tend to forget when it's "our guy" in charge.  When we gave President Bush the power to wire tap our phones to keep us safe, we also gave that power to future presidents who might not use the power so sparingly.  When we gave President Obama the power to overhaul the health care industry to keep us healthy, we also gave that power to future presidents, some of whom might not have our best health in mind.  When we gave Obama the power to spend trillions of our dollars to stimulate the economy and bailout corporations, even if it was the perfect solution to a terrible problem and everything works out wonderfully, we gave that same power to everyone else that comes after him.  And there's a chance that the next guy won't use that power and spend that money in such a perfect way. 

If you're reading this and trying to either defend or indict his policies that I meantioned, then you're missing the point.  This has nothing to do with Obama or his policies.  It has everything to do with the power he has.  Even if his policies are the perfect policies, we still shouldn't support him if those policies allow the president to have any power over the individual citizens.  If you love the man and think his policies are great, that's awesome and I'm glad you got the perfect president.  Just remember that the next guy probably won't be as perfect and you might wish the president didn't have so much power.  If you don't agree with what he's done and want to "take back Washington", remember this.  Because eventually your guy will get into office and he'll probably use the power to shuffle trillions of dollars, but in the way he wants to, and fight wars without approval from congress, but the ones that he wants to fight.  And it'll all be done because at some point we gave someone else the power to do that because we liked the way he used the power.

Just because someone is using their power in a way that you agree with doesn't mean the person should have that power.  In fact, it's even more important to deny a president more power when we approve of his policies because it's very likely that we won't object to a whole lot and we'll allow him a lot more power.  Hopefully all the people who support Obama think of this when discussing how good of a job he did at overhauling the health care industry, or stimulating the economy, or fighting pseudo-wars, or fixing the car industry, or stabilizing the housing market, or anything else that he did or does.  We shouldn't be asking if these policies are going to deliver good or bad results, we should be asking if we want to give so much power to a small number of people.  Because even if everything works out and the country is better because of these policies, it's still dangerous to give the president enough power to overhaul huge industries, distribute trillions of borrowed dollars however he sees fit, wage war without approval from congress and influence the price of homes.  Once we give that power away, it's nearly impossible to get it back and one day we might wake up and realize that we gave too much power to too few people.

I used the word "power" about 13,000 times and I just wanted to make the point that when someone has the ability to enact sweeping policy changes that are good, they also have the ability to enact sweeping policy changes that are bad.  And the best defense against this catch 22 is to not give our leaders that ability in the first place.  Keep the government as small as possible and leave the power with the millions of individual citizens, not whoever gets elected to office.  If we don't follow that one simple rule, one day we might have a president with so much power that he resembles Old Spice Odor Blocker Body Wash.  Then again, maybe that wouldn't be so bad either.


*I better clarify for the CIA, FBI, Secret Service and/or Fargo Police that might end up reading this.  I only mean to imply that he is a mortal human and because of that he will die at some point.  In no way should this line of reasoning be interpreted as a threat against President Obama or a suggestion to a lunatic.**

**Are there any lawyers out there who can let me know if I'm covering my bases here?  I don't want to go to jail over this.  And yes, I'm putting a footnote in a footnote.  Why would I do such a thing?  Because I can! I've gone mad with power!

Monday, October 25, 2010

How We Measure Inflation

I've been talking a lot about inflation lately.  But if you look at the traditional way we measure inflation, the Consumer Price Index (CPI), we are seeing inflation of 1.1% which isn't very much at all.  But like every number and statistic that you hear, you'll learn far more by looking at the methodology that was used to get that number or statistic.

Ostensibly, the CPI is a measure of consumer prices.  That is, an imaginary shopping cart full of goods from many different sectors of the economy (food, houses, cars, clothing, energy, etc.) is brought to the checkout and the price of all those goods is added up.  Then, one month later, the same imaginary shopping cart full of the same goods is brought to the checkout and the price is added again.  By doing some simple math you can figure out what the rate of inflation or deflation is by comparing the change in the price of your shopping cart's contents.  That seems like a very accurate and reasonable way to measure inflation, right?  I think it does.  And that's how the CPI is currently measured.  That's how the CPI was measured before the 1980's.  You see, modern economists and politicians have found some neat new ways to measure the price of those good in the shopping cart.  Let's take a look, shall we?

Alan Greenspan and Michael Boskin argued that changes to the CPI needed to be made for certain items when they became too expensive.  For instance, if the price of steak rose too high they should quit using steak in the CPI measurements and use hamburger instead.  They reasoned that once steak got to a certain price, the consumer would simply eat hamburger instead.  BAM!  Now inflation isn't as high.  Of course, this only shows the rate of inflation measured in terms of maintaining a lower standard of living.  Inflation stayed low on paper but in real life inflation was higher and living standards decreased.

Some years later there was another change that took place.  In addition to substituting cheaper goods for more expensive goods, the CPI started to use geometric weighting.  This means that when the month-to-month (or year-to-year) prices are calculated, more weight is given to prices that are falling, and less weight is given to prices that are rising.  If the price of bread has gone up 10% in the past month, but the price of milk has gone down 10%, then the official CPI measurement will give more weight to milk prices than bread prices, making the rate of inflation appear to be lower than it otherwise would.

More recently, the politicians and economists in charge have come up with a truly amazing new way to measure the CPI.  It's called hedonics, and it shows that these guys will stop at nothing to make inflation appear to be lower than it actually is.  Hedonics adjusts the price of goods for the increased pleasure the consumer derives from them.  That 20% increase in the price of your washing machine?  Well, that isn't going to be included in the CPI because of all the pleasure you get from pushing the fancy electronic buttons instead of turning the loud clicking wheel thing.  When the price of gas goes up due to federally mandated additives, it doesn't raise the inflation rate because the consumer got so much thrill from breathing the fresh air.

I've read that the real inflation rate (measuring CPI with the methods that were in place before all these changes) could be up to 7 or 8% higher than what the official measurements are.  And the Federal Reserve is making decisions based on a 1.1% inflation rate that they want to raise to about 2%.  But because they use such innovative ways to measure inflation, the real inflation rate will have to go up a lot more than 1% in order to get the official number to go up 1%.  I probably sound like a broken record but to me these are all signs that we're heading for an extremely high(er) rate of inflation.

If you're reading this you have access to the internet.  If you're curious about any of this just use the internet to watch the dollar index and commodity prices to see what inflation is doing.  The value of the dollar has been going down for some time and the price of sugar, cotton, corn, etc. has been going up.  When commodity prices (food) go up, and the value of the dollar goes down, you're seeing inflation.  The changes that I've been seeing in these two areas in recent months are significant.

The other day I was talking with someone about what I've been writing and I was told that I'm painting a really bleak picture.  I couldn't argue with that, but I had to clarify that what I'm describing is still the worst case scenario.  But with every passing day, and with every decision the Fed makes, the worst case scenario is looking more and more like the most likely scenario.

Pssst, that's not good.

Monday, October 11, 2010

WWIII: The Currency War

Believe it or not, we're in the midst of a war right now.  It's not Iraq or Afghanistan.  It's a war waged by the major governments of the world to destroy their own currency.  All across the world countries are enacting policies that devalue their own money.  It's a race to the bottom.  Last week, Brazilian Finance Minister Guido Mantega made headlines when he mentioned that a worldwide currency war was brewing, and the winner would be the nation with the weakest currency.

In a normal war countries try to kill the enemy.  In a currency war the countries point their guns at their own citizens and kill them with a currency that loses its purchasing power.  The country that can make its money worth the least is the country that wins the war.  The bad news is that the winner of this war will experience a Pyrrhic victory. The worse news is that America is poised to win this war.

Why on Earth would a country want to devalue its own currency?  That is such an easy question to ask because the premise makes absolutely no sense.  But the answer is actually quite complicated.  That's because modern economists have figured out a way to make it seem like a weaker currency is advantageous to a nation.  Of course, this is complete nonsense.  A weak currency is the result of bad policies that politicians love.  And if an economist can make it seem as though the terrible results of bad policies are actually desirable, well, that economist will probably get a job in the White House on the President's economic staff.  An economist who states otherwise (and speaks in terms of truth and common sense) isn't allowed in that elite club.

There are two reasons why a weaker currency would be desirable.  First, it helps the nation export more goods.  When your money isn't worth very much, it makes the goods you produce considerably cheaper to purchase.  When the price of goods is low, the amount of exports goes up.  Second, and this is related to the first point in a way, a weak currency leads to more jobs.  When the dollars that you pay workers in is worth less, it's more affordable to hire workers and the economy can create more jobs.  Politicians love this.  Debase the currency, raise exports, create jobs, get elected again.  On paper, everything works out perfectly.

Now, you might be thinking that this is what we need right now.  If a weaker dollar will create jobs then a weaker dollar we need.  But let me ask you something.  What's so great about a job?  There are very few people who work because they love labor so much.  Everyone in Soviet Russia had a job.  Every slave in early America had a job.  Seriously, the unemployment rate for black people in America during slavery was basically 0%.  There is nothing great about having a job.  The reason jobs are desirable is because having a job is a means to an end.  You earn money at your job and can use that money to buy stuff you want or need.  But by making that money worth less, which is what happens in a currency war, the people with jobs lose the ability to buy stuff with the money they earn.  Selling goods and having jobs become a means unto themselves and little attention is given to the fact that there are obvious negative effects of currency devaluation: diminished purchasing power and lower living standards.  Individuals see jobs as a means to an end.  Governments see jobs as an end in and of itself, and a devalued currency is the means to that end.

Way back in the 19th century, before economic models developed their current levels of sophistication, the goal of a government's economic policy was to bring prosperity to its citizens.  In other words, they tried to raise the general level of material comfort, while at the same time reducing the amount of toil and work needed to reach that end.  Unfortunately, due to the blather spouted by modern economists, success is no longer measured in those terms.  A country's currency used to be viewed much like a company's stock price.  The reliability, competitiveness, and growth of a national economy usually translated into a strong currency. This system made sense and it worked.

Countries that offered the most fertile soil for investment capital, or that made products other countries wanted, would attract funds from abroad. Demand for the currency of these “blue chip” countries (which was needed to invest or buy locally) would inevitably push up the value of the currency. And so, much as shareholders of successful companies are rewarded by higher stock prices, citizens of successful countries were rewarded with stronger currencies, with which they could buy more goods and services both domestically and internationally, raising their living standards.

But all that has changed in recent years. With a strategy that seems to be taken from the playbook of Sam Walton, governments now look to gain a competitive edge by lowering the cost of their exports. To do this, they have adopted a beggar thyself (as opposed to beggar thy neighbor) policy of habitual currency debasement. Although such a move may benefit those who buy the products, it is a burden to the country’s own workers who, like Wal-Mart employees, have to get by on lower wages. While the markets like a low-cost provider, this is not a niche that everyone can, or should, fill. Some will compete only on price, but more successful ventures will compete on quality and innovation. For every Kia there is a Mercedes Benz.  Nearly every country on Earth is attempting to compete by lowering the price of their goods and no thought is given to producing higher quality goods or developing innovative production techniques.

When a government debases its currency in order to gain sales overseas, the nation earns less for the goods that it exports. As a result, its comparative advantage is ruined, and its citizens consume less as a result. In other words, as a nation’s currency declines, its citizens are forced to work harder for less.

If a department store decided to have a sale in which all of its merchandise were marked down 50%, it will surely sell a lot more stuff.  However, it would earn a lot less than if it had been able to sell its goods without marking them down.  This is how currency debasement works.  Similarly, one way for the unemployed to get work is to accept lower wages.  Workers will sell a lot more of their labor if they accept 50% pay cuts.  But are they better off as a result? Relative to being unemployed, the answer is yes, but they would be much better off being employed at full pay.

As I pointed out earlier, the fact that America holds the world's reserve currency makes it easier for us to have a 50% off sale.  It also makes it easier for politicians to print money and inflate the currency at ridiculous levels.  Politicians love easy solutions so I'm convinced that extremely high inflation is on our horizon.  America is going to win the race to the bottom.  And eventually we're all going to be casualties of war.